Top 8 Restaurants in Scarsdale, NY

Scarsdale, NY features a vibrant culinary landscape offering 100% gluten-free Med-Mex fusion, table-side Korean barbecue, Michelin-rated Italian trattorias, and 40-year staple seafood markets within a 30-minute train ride from Midtown Manhattan in ZIP Code 10583.

Scarsdale has expanded its selection of dining establishments in town. Residents and food lovers from neighboring Westchester villages enjoy a variety of local flavors and atmosphere close to home, without needing to commute into New York City. Whether you are a long-time resident, recent transplant, or evaluating Scarsdale homes for sale, explore these top local restaurants in the village center and Garth Road commercial corridors.

Best Local Restaurants in Scarsdale

1. Popojito (Med-Mex Kitchen)

For a lunch or dinner featuring international flavor combinations, visit Popojito on Christie Place. This 100% gluten-free restaurant combines Mexican culinary traditions with Mediterranean ingredients. The industrial interior includes floor-to-ceiling windows, complemented by an outdoor sidewalk patio.

• Location: 46 Christie Pl, Scarsdale, NY 10583 | Scarsdale Village Center
• Menu Highlights: Calamari Mexicano with chipotle aioli, short rib tacos, octopus and mango pineapple pico, chimichurri skirt steak
• Dietary Accommodation: 100% Certified Gluten-Free Kitchen

Starter dishes include calamari Mexicano with jalapeno and chipotle aioli. Tacos are served in soft corn tortillas or lettuce wraps with choices like braised short rib or octopus pico. Entrees feature chimichurri skirt steak paired with truffle mashed potatoes alongside a full margarita menu.

2. Yeomiji (Korean Barbecue)

Yeomiji brings table-side Korean barbecue to Spencer Place in downtown Scarsdale. Housed in a historic exposed brick building, the restaurant features front porch seating and a long interior dining bar.

• Location: 13 Spencer Pl, Scarsdale, NY 10583 | Near Scarsdale Metro-North Station
• Menu Highlights: Table-side grilled bulgogi, soy-marinated short ribs, Korean kimchi pancakes, salmon sashimi bibimbap
• Dining Options: In-house table-side grilling, bar seating, front porch dining

Menu offerings start with savory Korean pancakes filled with vegetables, kimchi, and seafood. Main dining options include table-grilled soy-marinated short ribs, bulgogi, and bibimbap served in crisp rice bowls topped with salmon sashimi or spicy sauteed pork.

Source: Westchester Magazine Dining Guide and Scarsdale Chamber of Commerce Directory.

3. One Rare Steakhouse

One Rare Italian Steakhouse on East Parkway combines prime steakhouse dining with traditional Italian pasta recipes in a modern interior setting designed for special events and formal dinners.

• Location: 16 East Pkwy, Scarsdale, NY 10583 | Facing Scarsdale Station Plaza
• Menu Highlights: On-site dry-aged Tomahawk, Wagyu beef, Tagliatelle Bolognese, Linguini Frutti di Mare
• Features: Dedicated dry-aging room, curated wine cellar, craft cocktail bar

The kitchen operates an in-house dry-aging box for its beef cuts, offering Tomahawk steaks, Wagyu beef, ribeye, and filet mignon served with specialty house sauces. The pasta menu includes Tagliatelle Bolognese and Linguini Frutti di Mare.

4. Cafe Alaia (Italian)

Cafe Alaia on Garth Road is a recognized Italian trattoria awarded the Michelin Bib Gourmand honor. The intimate dining room offers traditional regional Italian plates for lunch and dinner service.

• Location: 128 Garth Rd, Scarsdale, NY 10583 | Garth Road Commercial District
• Menu Highlights: Specialty house crostini, Caprese antipasti, Impepata di Cozze, Gnocchi al Pesto, Salmone in Padella
• Accolades: Michelin Guide Bib Gourmand Recipient

Appetizers feature house-made specialty crostini with seasonal toppings, Caprese salad, and Impepata di Cozze (peppered mussels). Signature main courses include Gnocchi al Pesto and pan-seared Salmone in Padella.

5. Tipsy Taco Bar

Tipsy Taco Bar provides organic Mexican cooking on Garth Road. Operating with a 90% gluten-free menu, the kitchen emphasizes organic meats and scratch-made salsas across lunch, dinner, and weekend brunch.

• Location: 56 Garth Rd, Scarsdale, NY 10583 | Garth Road Corridor
• Menu Highlights: Tipsy Benedictos (Brunch), handmade empanadas, street tacos, enchiladas, fajitas
• Dietary Options: 90% Gluten-Free Menu | Organic Meats

Brunch items include Tipsy Benedictos (poached eggs with Mexican spices), while daily menus offer empanadas, street tacos, enchiladas, and fajitas paired with fresh fruit margaritas.

Source: Michelin Guide New York and Village of Scarsdale Business Listings.

6. Moscato Ristorante

Moscato Ristorante on Scarsdale Avenue is an upscale Italian establishment known for professional service, outdoor al fresco patio seating, and house-made breads and desserts baked fresh on-site daily.

• Location: 874 Scarsdale Ave, Scarsdale, NY 10583 | Near Garth Road Junction
• Menu Highlights: Three-Course Pre-Fixe Lunch, Burrata, Calamari Fritti, Zuppa di Pesce, Pollo alla Cacciatora
• Amenities: Al fresco patio dining, private event catering, on-site bakery

Lunch service includes a popular Three-Course Pre-Fixe menu featuring choices of appetizers (burrata, calamari fritti), soups, and over ten pasta selections. Dinner offerings highlight Zuppa di Pesce and Pollo alla Cacciatora.

7. Akai Scarsdale (Japanese)

Akai on Spencer Place serves modern Japanese cuisine and sushi. The contemporary space offers daily-delivered fresh fish, sake selections, specialty martinis, and organized menu sections tailored to diner preferences.

• Location: 57 Spencer Pl, Scarsdale, NY 10583 | Downtown Scarsdale Village
• Menu Highlights: Super California roll, Dynamite roll, raw sushi/sashimi platters, Japanese noodle soups
• Services: Dine-in sushi bar, takeout, local delivery

The menu categorizes options for both raw sushi enthusiasts and diners preferring cooked dishes, featuring cooked rolls (Super California, Dynamite), Japanese noodle soups, and teriyaki entrees.

8. Eastchester Fish Gourmet

Operating for over 40 years on White Plains Road, Eastchester Fish Gourmet encompasses a fine dining restaurant, fish market, and counter-service eatery known for daily fresh seafood deliveries.

• Location: 837 White Plains Rd, Scarsdale, NY 10583 | Lord & Taylor Shopping Plaza Area
• Menu Highlights: Kumamoto & Pink Moon oysters, Tsar-cut smoked salmon, Dover Sole in brown butter
• Establishment: 40+ Years in Scarsdale | Daily Changing Dinner Menu & Fresh Fish Market

The restaurant updates its dinner menu nightly based on market availability. Raw bar offerings include West Coast Kumamoto oysters and Prince Edward Island Pink Moon oysters, alongside Petrossian Tsar-cut smoked salmon and Dover Sole served in brown butter sauce.

Source: Zagat Survey Westchester and Westchester Magazine Best of County Awards.

Frequently Asked Questions About Dining in Scarsdale

Where are the main restaurant districts located in Scarsdale?

Scarsdale's primary dining destinations are concentrated in the historic Tudor Village Center (Christie Place, Spencer Place, East Parkway) and along the Garth Road and Scarsdale Avenue commercial corridors near the Metro-North station.

Are there gluten-free restaurant options in Scarsdale?

Yes. Popojito on Christie Place operates a 100% gluten-free Med-Mex kitchen, while Tipsy Taco Bar on Garth Road features a 90% gluten-free menu using organic meats.

Which Scarsdale restaurants offer outdoor al fresco dining?

Outdoor dining patio setups are available at Popojito, Chat American Grill, Tipsy Taco Bar, Moscato Ristorante, and Yeomiji during spring, summer, and autumn months.